For a better view on Diamond Properties, Update Your Browser.



Integrity. Expertise. Professionalism. That’s what I looked for when I sought a real estate professional to sell one of my properties in Cayman. My research pointed me to Paula McCartney with Diamond Properties. With a make-it-happen attitude, a strong business background, a solid reputation of competence and integrity, Paula sets the Gold Standard with her concierge-style customer service in the real estate industry.

A “start to finish” broker, Paula expertly and thoroughly guided me through the selling of my property. She prides herself on her hands-on involvement at all stages of the process and went to great lengths to make it happen within my personal timeframe. I found great assurance in her kind, authentic, straight-forward demeanor, effective communication and problem-solving abilities. I always felt like I was Paula and her team’s top priority. From June 2020 to Dec 2020, Paula brought me five offers. Yes, you read that right. FIVE!!!

Paula and her Business Manager, Tanya March went the extra mile, on this transaction. This team understands the fact that real estate is not about dealing with property, it’s about helping people! Diamond Properties’ winning combination of aggressiveness, tenacity, perseverance and strategy resulted in me being one heck of a happy customer!! I’ve found an incredible realtor and lifelong friends!

Selling or buying in Cayman? Hire Diamond Properties, you’ll be so glad you did!


Whole process smooth from start to finish!

We just purchased our first home with the help from Tash at Diamond Properties, and don't think We could have done it without her! We were looking at the market on our own when Tash reached out to help us. With her help, we narrowed down what we were looking for, and were promptly viewing any properties that met our criteria. We quickly came across the right fit, and moved in within 6 weeks of viewing! We can't thank Tash and the Diamond Properties team enough, they really made the whole process smooth from start to finish.

Tricia Hildred

We found a realtor & a lifelong friend!

Paula goes above and beyond in every possible way. She will actually guide you through the process of buying in Cayman and has the experience to help you find the right property at the right price. She makes sure that your home is not just right for you today but a good investment for your family’s future. We not only found a realtor but a lifelong friend.

Gordon Goss

She is the One!

Paula did an outstanding job helping us acquire our Grand Cayman beach front condominium. We could not have been more pleased with her, both personally and professionally! We have bought many properties over the years and dealt with numerous agents, but Paula’s performance exceeded our highest expectations. Her extensive knowledge of the Islands made the shopping process a breeze. During the entire time,she kept us updated on all developments. It did not matter what time day or night; her response time was flawless. If you’re looking for the absolute best agent on the Island,she is the One!

William B

Great Experience!

Great experience from start to finish with Diamond Properties. Paula was utterly focused on our house sale. From finding us a buyer to closing, she held our hand from start to finish.

Catherine & Adrian Porter

Diamond Properties… truly a rare gem!

We wanted to share what a smooth & stress-free experience this has been because of the way you service your clients. Truly above & beyond with helping us clear hurdles and handling the process like a pro. Not only that, but I really loved all the positive energy that comes through whenever you gave us an update. You clearly really love your job and some of the "We got this!!!" vibe transferred to me when I needed it the most! Diamond Properties… truly a rare gem!

M & A Barceló

Courteous, Committed and Caring

I would highly recommend Diamond Properties to anyone wishing to sell or buy a home. Paula did an outstanding job negotiating the sale of my home and went above and beyond my expectations with what I’ve experienced with other estate agents. Courteous, committed and caring from start to finish and above all else, honest! I was extremely impressed by the professionalism shown by Paula and I can’t thank her enough for working so hard to ensure the sale went through successfully.

D. Ashurst

Finally! An upstanding realtor!

Words cannot express the gratitude I feel for Paula and Diamond Properties. Paula worked tirelessly from start to finish on our project. She went above and beyond in every way that was needed. She not only helped us with our paperwork to ensure when closing time came all was in order, but she helped us through all the bumps, all the red tape and ensured that we closed in a timely manner. Not to mention getting the best offer we could on the table. Being off island makes it all the more complicated; however, Paula worked diligently to make sure everything was taken care of and handled without a problem. She is forthright, forthcoming and extremely knowledgeable in her business. She was worth every penny of her commission and more. Finally! An upstanding realtor who doesn’t make you feel that it’s all about the sale.

Elizabeth C.

Concierge Service Made it Easy!

You found the perfect place for us, based on our wants, and helped us to make it ours! You are incredibly professional and so easy to work with! Your concierge service is what made this ‘easy’! Thank you so much! We will certainly recommend you!

Linda and Rob D.

Everything We Could Ask For!

You were everything we could ask for in an agent to help us with the due diligence process.

Matt and Christan F.

Above & Beyond!

Great that it turned out and you are right, it has been a long haul. Thank you very much for all your support throughout the process. Truly above and beyond.

Jason and Jing Z.